1 min read
Why Traditional Group Long-Term Disability Plans Fail High Earners
Blind spot monitors were first introduced by Volvo in 2001 to solve a critical problem: even the most experienced drivers can’t see everything. These...
2 min read
How Critical Plans May Fall Short When It Counts Most
Imagine designing what you think to be a high-quality home, only to discover it wasn’t constructed to withstand a storm.
That’s the reality behind many executive compensation benefit plans: they may seem thoughtfully conceived on the surface, with a well-crafted mix of salary, bonuses and equity. But dig a little deeper, and you’ll often find that the benefits designed to protect those earnings—disability coverage, life insurance, and retirement programs—prove to be structural vulnerabilities that too often remain unseen until tested.
And by the time they’re tested, it’s usually too late to fix them.
Companies devote considerable resources, time and money designing effective executive compensation packages. However, the supporting benefits—disability, life insurance, retirement—often receive less attention, despite being critical to preserving both income and long-term financial security. The very programs meant to support high earners’ asset accumulation and protection against income loss and financial instability often fail to scale with the size and structure of their success.
Cracks in the Foundation
Even the most polished compensation strategy can conceal flaws beneath the surface. For highly compensated employees, those flaws often take shape in three areas:
- Group Long-Term Disability (LTD) insurance typically replaces only 60% of base salary, subject to a monthly maximum, and in many situations, excludes significant executive compensation elements such as bonuses, commissions and equity.
- Group Life insurance provided by employers often caps at 1-2 times base salary, frequently with a limited maximum benefit, leaving total income and future earnings potential unaccounted for.
- Qualified retirement plans like 401(k)’s are constrained by IRS limits that don’t scale with higher incomes, restricting the ability to defer sufficient income on a tax-advantaged basis.
These shortcomings, each significant on their own, together are amplified. They can destabilize the financial foundation executives have worked hard to build.
When the Storm Hits
Picture a high earner who becomes disabled. Their Group LTD may kick in, but it only replaces a limited percentage of their earnings. They’re not just losing a paycheck; they’re often only getting a portion of their base salary and none of their bonus or equity. On top of that, they lose the ability to fund retirement accounts. In a single moment, two underpinnings—current income and future financial security—are compromised. Should the life-altering disability result in death, the family may be left with minimal life insurance coverage, far below what’s needed to maintain financial stability.
The illusion of sufficient coverage disappears quickly in these moments. These benefits are more than individual safety nets—they are interconnected supports holding up a much larger structure. If one fails, the impact is often compounded by the others.
A Smarter Blueprint
Building a better house or in this case—a stronger benefits foundation—starts by viewing these programs through the lens of today’s high earners. That means applying the same rigor and customization to benefits as is given to compensation design. There’s no universal solution, but there are common upgrades worth exploring:
-
Reengineer disability coverage to reflect total compensation. Supplemental Individual Disability Insurance (IDI) can fill the gap left by most Group LTD by taking into account all compensation elements. These policies can incorporate tax efficiency and are portable, offering continuity even after employment changes. They remove the monthly benefits ceilings that limit traditional plans, making full income protection possible.
-
Modernize life insurance to reflect both current and future earnings power. A layered approach—combining group coverage with employer-sponsored or voluntary individual life policies—can offer scalable, portable protection. For some executives, split-dollar or permanent life insurance may offer additional advantages, including long-term cash value accumulation.
-
Expand retirement opportunities beyond IRS limits. High earners often max out their 401(k) plan early in the year. Employers can open additional retirement savings capacity through Nonqualified Deferred Compensation (NQDC) plans or Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans (SERPs) enabling additional pretax savings and better retirement readiness.
Start Building Smarter
If you’re unsure how your current benefits stack up, or if you want to ensure your compensation structure holds up under pressure, let’s connect. TIP works alongside benefits brokers and company leaders to assess risk, identify gaps and implement strategic, modern solutions that support top talent.
The foundation you build today will determine how well you weather tomorrow.
Let’s build something stronger—together.
3 min read
The Inflated Price of Group High Max LTD Plans And What to Do About It
“Between the various loads and pricing actions underwriters apply to high max LTD plans, employers can end up with rates 30% or higher
